Sometimes peer review delays progress for many decades

(written by lawrence krubner, however indented passages are often quotes). You can contact lawrence at:, or follow me on Twitter.

This is what real leadership looks like:

Morris intentionally consumes H. pylori. Like Marshall, he becomes ill, but unlike Marshall, he is not completely cured by antibiotics. The infection will remain with him for three years.

I wish he had been given a medal for his self-sacrifice. He was attempting to save millions from suffering.

Interesting, though very disappointing:

Klebs notes the presence of bacteria-like organisms in the lumen of the gastric glands.

Walery Jaworski describes spiral organisms in sediment washings of humans. He suggests these organisms might be involved with gastric disease.

Giulio Bizzozero observes spiral organisms in the stomach of dogs.

Spirochete bacteria

Saloon finds spirochetes in the stomachs of cats and mice.

F. Reigel suggests that ulcers are caused by excess acid.

Bacillus coli (E. coli)

Krienitz finds bacteria in the stomach of people with gastric cancer.
Turck feeds dogs Bacillus coli and produces ulcers.

Berkley Moynihan suggests that acid is a cause of ulcers.

Schwartz publishes the excess acid theory of the ulcer, coining the famous phrase “no acid, no ulcer.”
Gibelli claims to be unable to reproduce Turck’s study where he artificially created ulcers by feeding dogs bacteria.


Rosenow suggests that streptococci produce ulcers.

Antacids are first recommended for the treatment of PUD.
Bacteria are associated with PUD, but it is assumed that the bacteria reside in the mouth.

Katsuya Kasai and Rokuzo Kobayashi isolate spirochetes in cats and transmit them to rabbits, producing ulcers.

Luger discovers spirochetes in the gastric juice, and associates their presence with gastric cancer.


Luck and Seth discover urease in the human stomach, which they believe is naturally occurring.

Hoffman injects a small sample from a human with PUD into a guinea pig, producing ulcers, and isolates a bacterium which he believes caused the ulcers.

First edition of the Russian Large Medical Encyclopedia suggests infection is one of the causes of PUD.

A. Stone Freedberg begins a study to look for bacteria in the human stomach at Beth Israel Hospital. He finds H. pylori. It is rumored that others cannot reproduce the results, although no negative results are published.
James Doenges describes spirochetes in autopsies.

Freedberg and Baron observe spirochetes in autopsies. Freedberg abandons his research, however, after his boss advises him to move to another subject. In 2005, Marshall speculates that Freedberg would have won the Nobel Prize in 1951 had he continued his work.

Fitzgerald and Murphy hypothesize that PUD is caused by acid eating away mucosa, and demonstrate the effectiveness of urea as a treatment for PUD.

J. Allende publishes a book describing the treatment of gastric ulcers with penicillin.

Dintzis and Hastings are able to stop urease production in mice with antibiotics, suggesting a relationship between urease and a bacterial infection.

Palmer publishes a study which finds no bacteria in the human stomach. He concludes earlier discoveries were a result of contamination. Unfortunately, he chooses not to use a silver staining method, which will be later used to reveal H. pylori by Warren and Marshall.[20]

Tarnopolskaya observes that penicillin seems to cure some peptic ulcers.
Moutier and Cornet suggest treating gastritis with antibiotics.
Kornberg and Davies observe that antibiotics reduce urease in cats.[21]


Charles Lieber and Andre Lefèvre discover that antibiotics reduce gastric urea to ammonia conversion.[22]

Gordon observes that penicillin cures some peptic ulcers.
John Lykoudis successfully treats his own gastroenteritis with antibiotics.[23]
Lieber and Lefèvre present their results at the World Congress of Gastroenterology in Washington. It is not well received because of the widespread belief that bacteria cannot survive in the human stomach, due to Palmer.[24]

Lieber and Lefèvre publish a follow-up study demonstrating that antibiotics prevent the conversion of urea to ammonia in the human stomach.[25]
Conway et al. call into question the extent of urease produced by bacteria in mice, as an argument against the bacterial theory of PUD.[26]

Campylobacter fetus

Vital and Orrego observe Campylobacter-like organisms in the stomachs of cats and dogs.[27]
Lykoudis is awarded a Greek patent (#22,453) for his antibiotic treatment of PUD.[23]

Susser and Stein publish a paper identifying a cohort phenomenon of PUD in England. This is taken as evidence for stress causing PUD.[28]

Lykoudis presents his antibiotic treatment for PUD at a meeting of the Medico-Surgical Society in Greece. He is largely shunned by the medical establishment.[23]

Lykoudis’ manuscript is rejected by the Journal of the American Medical Association.[23]

Susumu Ito describes Campylobacter-like organisms attached to a gastric epithelial cell.[29]

Lykoudis is fined 4,000 drachmas for treating PUD patients with his treatment, which includes antibiotics.[23]

Howard Steer observes H. pylori from biopsies of a patient with ulcers.

The first report of successfully using furazolidone (an antibacterial agent) to treat PUD in China.

Morozov observes H. pylori; he does not connect this discovery to PUD.
A well regarded study of PUD is published which does not mention bacteria.

Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Steer and Colin-Jones publish their results regarding H. pylori and its relation to PUD. They decide that it was Pseudomonas, a contaminant, and not related to PUD.

At a meeting of the American Gastroenterology Association in Las Vegas, several papers are presented which suggest that acid control via H2 blockers is ineffective at curing PUD.

Ramsey publishes a study demonstrating that bismuth can help eradicate PUD. Bismuth is an antibacterial agent, although this is not recognized by Ramsey.
J. Robin Warren first observes H. pylori in a gastric biopsy.
Fung, Papadimitriou, and Matz observe H. pylori.

Yao Shi observes bacteria in the stomach, but he believes they are passing through the stomach and not colonizing it.
July: Barry Marshall joins gastroenterology division of Royal Perth Hospital and meets Robin Warren
October: Marshall and Warren successfully treat their first PUD patient with antibiotics.

Satoha et al. find evidence for an infectious cause of ulcers in rats.
Marshall and Warren begin their first study to determine the relationship between H. pylori and PUD.
First successful culturing of H. pylori performed; it occurs almost by accident.
October: Marshall discovers the bacteria he is investigating are not campylobacteria, by looking at electron micrographs.
October 2: Marshall presents his and Warren’s results at a local College of Physicians meeting. He meets with criticism, which Marshall later admits was well-founded (at least in part).


January: Two letters authored by Warren and Marshall, respectively, are sent to The Lancet describing their results.
February: Gastroenterological Society of Australia rejects Marshall’s abstract to present his research at their yearly conference. They deem it in the bottom 10% of papers submitted. The same abstract is accepted for presentation at a Campylobacter workshop in Brussels.
April: Marshall and Ian Hislop begin a study to compare bismuth treatment with cimetidine. The study is abandoned because it is inconclusive.
June: Warren and Marshall’s letter appears in The Lancet.
September: H. pylori is observed in patients outside of Australia.
After the appearance of the letters in The Lancet, groups around the world begin isolating H. pylori.

A paper describing Marshall and Warren’s results is accepted by the Gastroenterological Society of Australia for presentation.
Marshall and Goodwin attempt to infect pigs with H. pylori in an attempt to demonstrate that it causes PUD. The experiment fails.
Marshall and Warren’s paper is accepted by The Lancet in May and published in June. Many reviewers dislike the paper.
McNulty and Watson are able to reproduce Marshall and Warren’s results.
June 12: Marshall intentionally consumes H. pylori and becomes ill. He takes antibiotics and is relieved of his symptoms.
The National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia fully funds Marshall’s research into H. pylori.
A study is published in China about the effectiveness of treating PUD with an antibacterial agent.
July 31: The New York Times publishes an article by its medical correspondent Dr. Lawrence K. Altman on the possible link between H. pylori and PUD. He states in 2002, “I’ve never seen the medical community more defensive or more critical of a story” since he joined the newspaper in 1969.

Marshall publishes the results of self-induced infection.

Drumm and colleagues following a study of children reported in the New England Journal of Medicine that Helicobacter pylori was specifically associated with primary or unexplained gastric inflammation and primary duodenal ulceration whereas the bacteria was not found in association with secondary gastric inflammation and ulcers due to causes such as Crohn’s disease or critical illness. Because gastritis and duodenal ulceration are rare in children this study had the capacity to demonstrate that Warren and Marshall were correct in claiming that H. pylori was a specific pathogen rather than as had been suggested by some, merely an opportunistic colonizer of an inflamed or ulcerated mucosal surface. This was the first time that New England Journal of Medicine, the worlds leading medical journal published a study on Helicobacter pylori.

Morris intentionally consumes H. pylori. Like Marshall, he becomes ill, but unlike Marshall, he is not completely cured by antibiotics. The infection will remain with him for three years.
An extensive study in Dublin demonstrates that eradicating H. pylori substantially reduces recurrence of ulcers.

Rauws and Tytgat describe cure of duodenal ulcer by eradication of H. pylori using a triple-therapy regimen, consisting of bismuth and two antibiotics. Triple-therapy, modernized to a proton pump inhibitor and two antibiotics, soon becomes first line therapy for eradication.
World Congress of Gastroenterology recommends eradicating H. pylori to cure duodenal ulcers.
First report of resistance of H. pylori to the antibiotic metronidazole. Resistance of H. pylori to treatment will lead to the development of many different antibiotic and proton pump inhibitor regimens for eradication.[50]

Fukuda et al. prove ingestion of H. pylori causes gastritis in rhesus monkeys.
Covacci et al. sequence the CagA gene, which encodes for a cytotoxin-associated surface protein, which correlated strongly with strains of H. pylori that caused duodenal ulcers. This was the first description of a virulence factor for H. pylori infection determined by molecular techniques.[51]

Gastric cancer

Fujioka et al. prove similar results as those from Fukuda et al.
Patents for acid reducing drugs expire, removing financial incentive to resist antibiotics as treatment of PUD.
A conference held by National Institute of Health (USA) demonstrates the general acceptance of H. pylori as cause of PUD in the US.
The World Health Organization’s International Agency for Research on Cancer declares H. pylori a Group 1 carcinogen.
Parsonnet et al. describe an association between H. pylori and lymphomas of the gastrointestinal tract. These malignant ulcers can also be treated by eradicating Helicobacter.

Post external references

  1. 1